I'm the office administrator for a 220-person company. In practice, that means I manage all the lower-stakes purchasing—roughly $180k annually across a dozen vendors. I report to both operations and finance. My job is to keep everything running, from the crawler crane in the yard to the front-load washer in the crew laundry room. And after five years in this role, I can tell you: there's no single right way to buy replacement parts.
It's tempting to think you can just compare prices and specs. But identical specs from different sources can wind up costing you very differently in downtime, compliance, and frustration. So let me break this down by four scenarios that cover just about every purchasing decision I handle these days.
If a part fails in a crane, people get hurt. Not a maybe. So for Manitowoc cranes and telehandlers, I always order original OEM parts from the Manitowoc crane group network. No exceptions. That includes pins, seals, hydraulic filters, boom sections—everything. The price difference might look ugly at first, but the total cost of a failure is the real price.
People think OEM is just a brand markup. Actually, it's the opposite: the reason Manitowoc can charge more is that the part has been tested to specific load ratings and tolerances. I learned this the hard way. In 2022, a supplier pitched me a batch of 'will-fit' hydraulic filters for a 50-ton lattice boom crane. They fit perfectly and cost 40% less. They also ruptured at 70% of the rated pressure in independent lab testing. (Luckily, I requested the test report before install—that was close.)
Now I have a simple rule: if failure means injury, death, or a load dropping, it's OEM. I verify the serial number on the machine itself before ordering. I don't trust memory or the old parts list hanging in the workshop. A serial number mix-up once cost us a week of downtime. That's a mistake you only make once.
Here things get interesting. A Manitowoc ice machine is a critical piece of equipment in a commercial kitchen, but its failure is not life-threatening. So the OEM vs. aftermarket question becomes a real one. There are distributors—like PartsFPS, which sells OEM replacement parts for Manitowoc ice machines—and there are generic suppliers that claim compatibility.
My advice: stick with OEM for anything that contacts water or ice, plus any electrical or refrigerant components. Water pumps, valves, seals, thermostats—these need to meet food-grade and sanitation standards. The FTC's advertising guidelines say any claim that a product is 'same as OEM' must be substantiated. If a seller can't show you a test report or a traceable supply chain, that's a red flag. Per FTC guidance, 'better than OEM' claims are even harder to prove.
I was once tempted to save 30% on an aftermarket water pump for a Manitowoc ice machine. The spec sheet looked fine. The pump failed after three months. We had to shut down the machine for a day, and the health inspector came by that same week. (Surprise, surprise—not a good combination.) The replacement labor and lost product cost more than the original OEM pump would have. I should add that the machine manufacturer's warranty now required a certified part anyway.
For small consumables like hoses and gaskets, you can be a bit more flexible. But even then, I order through a verified supplier that can tell me the OEM part number. Most online suppliers will ship small seals via USPS Priority Mail—or rather, that's the quickest method we've seen for a two-day arrival.
Commercial vehicles sit in the middle of the risk spectrum. A failure in the brake system, steering, or lights is a safety issue and a compliance issue. But body panels, mirrors, and trim? Those are fair game for aftermarket parts.
Our garbage truck goes through a DOT inspection every year. The inspector flagged a non-OEM taillight marker on the first try—the color was slightly off. That cost us a re-inspection fee and a half-day in the shop. Since then, I treat anything that affects inspection as OEM or certified remanufactured. Same with brake parts and suspension components. Our Shelby truck is a specialty vehicle, and parts for it are harder to find; I've learned to verify the vendor's history before experimenting.
Here's the pitfall: I once saved $120 on aftermarket brake pads for the Shelby truck. The pads were cheap, but a week later the truck pulled hard to one side. The friction material was uneven, and it ruined the rotors. Total cost: $650 for new rotors, plus a day of downtime. Net loss: more than the 'expensive' OEM pads would have been. (Note to self: now I ask about shear strength and friction rating before buying anything that stops a 5-ton vehicle.)
For less critical parts—like a tailgate seal for the garbage truck or a mirror arm—aftermarket is fine if the supplier can point to a fleet reference. But always document the part number and keep the proof of purchase. Compliance inspections can come at you fast.
This is where the standardized advice collapses. If a washing machine part fails, nobody gets hurt and the health inspector doesn't care. Generic parts are often perfectly fine. More importantly, many so-called part failures are actually maintenance failures.
If you're searching for 'how to clean washing machine front loader' because yours smells, stop before you buy any parts. The fix is usually a cleaning cycle with vinegar and baking soda, wiping down the door seal, and leaving the door ajar when it's not in use. We put a monthly calendar reminder for that—it cut our washer service calls by about 60%.
For actual repairs, like a worn door boot or a broken belt, aftermarket components with good reviews and a return policy are acceptable. I once went back and forth between OEM and aftermarket for a washer drain pump for two weeks. OEM offered proven reliability; aftermarket was 40% cheaper. I chose the aftermarket one because the machine was nine years old and I didn't need it to last another decade. It's still running after a year, so that worked out.
If you're torn between OEM and aftermarket, don't just do the math on sticker price. Ask these four questions:
If you can't answer all four clearly, default to OEM. It's not the cheapest option, but it's the safest one. And in my experience, the cost of a non-OEM failure almost always exceeds the markup you were trying to avoid.
An informed customer asks better questions and makes faster decisions. That's why I'd rather spend ten minutes explaining these trade-offs than deal with mismatched expectations later. Whether you're buying a hydraulic cartridge for a Manitowoc crane or figuring out a front-loader cleaning schedule, knowing which scenario you're in is the first step. After that, the right choice usually gets a lot clearer.
Our application engineers provide lift-plan-specific recommendations at no charge.
Ask an Engineer